I want to expand the tools I have at my disposal so I can actually excecute more of the little ideas I have. Building mechanical parts from metals & plastics, milling PCB’s. A small milling machine may fit the bill. Looking for a suitable milling machine I searched the internet for information. After checking my budget, I found my options were limited.
|Proxxon MF70||Sieg X1 Micro Mill|
|These numbers come from their respective datasheets. For numbers in inches see: MF 70 and Sieg Ind.|
|Speed||5,000 – 20,000 rpm||100 – 1000, 100 – 2000 rpm|
|Taper / Collet sizes||1.0 – 1.5 – 2.0 – 2.35 – 3.0 – 3.2 mm collets||MT2|
|Table Size||200 x 70 mm||240 x 145 mm|
|X-Y Travel||134 x 46 mm||180 x 90 mm|
|Vertical Travel||70mm||30mm (fine) / 230 mm (coarse)|
|Overall size||130 x 225 x 340 mm||430 x 355 x 690 mm|
|Max. Power||100 W||150 W|
|Volts||220 – 240 V, 50/60 Hz.||220 – 240 V, 50/60 Hz.|
|Weight||7 kg||32 kg|
There’s a lot of information available for DIY-converting these manual machines to CNC (Computer Numerical Control), plenty of people have done so succesfully and documented their efforts in great detail. If you’re still operating it by hand, which is a good way to get familiar with it, make sure to read this guide on adjusting the X1 properly.
How did I choose my machine?
The MF70 is the lighter & smaller machine of the two, with much less weight (7 kg) and little less motor power (100 W). It does have a much higher spindle speed. This allows it to use much smaller diameter milling bits (1.0 to 3.2 mm shank with the collects I found available) and makes it suitable for fine work, like juwelry and model building.
The X1 has a slightly more powerfull motor (150 W), and with it’s MT2 taper it takes Morse Taper 2 collets for any diameter mill bits. The X1 allows for larger parts to be made because of it larger table travel, nearly twice in the Y-axis. The weight difference suggests it to be of a more sturdy construction as well, so for tougher jobs the X1 would be better suited. The Z-axis of the mills are different in design.
The MF70 uses a single handle to adjust the height of the toolhead. The X1 has a seperate handle for the coarse and fine mechanism. The coarse mechanism is located near the top and back of the machine. It adjusts the overall position of the spindle motor used a handle like the ones for X and Y. The fine mechanism can be operated in 2 ways. The larger handle at the right operates like your average drill-press.
You press down, the drilling head moves down and a hole is drilled. A mechanical switch opposite the handle engage the smaller handle at front. This allows you to much more finely adjust the Z position of the tool. Both of these 2 ways have a limit of ~30mm. The coarse Z-adjustment at the top/back allows for ~230mm of travel.
Availability of the mill
Proxxon is a fairly well known brand in The Netherlands.
A few retailers in Amsterdam sell their products:
IJzerhandel van Kalken
van den Berge IJzerwaren
Online you can buy the MF70 at conrad.nl. Buitelaar sells it too.
Sieg, on the other hand, remains completely unknown and unmarketed. The only retail store in the The Netherlands where I could find a (rebranded) Sieg machine is Buitelaar.
Since they had a good price, I bought it there, and picked it up.
Abroad it’s sold by various hardware stores:
United States : Harbor Freight, Grizzly, Micro-Mark, Homier, Smithy
United Kingdom : Arc Euro Trade, Axminster, MachineMart.
Germany : Rotwerk, Jeddeloh, Ar-Tec
Some of the stores no longer sell the X1 series, but start at the largers models like the X2, or the slightly different SX1 (tiltable column).
If you know about retail- or webstores that sell the X1, SX1 or X2, let me know!
Availability of cnc conversion-kits
If you have chosen a run-off-the-mill-mill there might be kits available for your machine. This goes for motors, drivers and controllerboards too. Especially on the mechanical construction buying a kit will save you an infinite amount of time, but takes away the fun of building it yourself.
The availability of CNC conversion kits for the MF70 like the one sold by USOVO USOVO and KDN Tool make it a temping offer. These kits make it really easy to transform a manual millling machine to a CNC operated one. If you plan to do the conversion yourself, be prepared to spend a great deal of time on it.
For the X1 a few kits are available too. Again KDN Tool offers one, and CNCFusion another one.
this page is in the slow process of being updated.